By LUIS A. ALEJO, Monterey County Supervisor
Editor’s note: This is a rebuttal to an editorial that aired on KSBW on Jan. 18. The editorial can be viewed at www.tinyurl.com/ybyzbhdq.
There’s an old attorney’s adage that states: “If you have the law on your side, argue the law; if you have the facts, argue the facts; if you have neither, pound the table.” The highly misleading TV editorial by KSBW’s conservative station manager JW Heston, that aired during MLK weekend, is his pounding on the table, but with words I never said.
In his two-minute attack piece, Heston responds to my tweets about his prior editorial that criticized California’s sanctuary state law and politicized the tragic death of Newman Police Office Ronil Singh. However, he falsely states, “Alejo is wrong to inject race and ethnicity into either of these situations,” titled the editorial, “Ethnic Divisiveness,” and wrongly claimed that I said KSBW should focus on another cop killer being “a white man.”
However, I never stated any such things. I never mentioned “race” or “ethnicity” and certainly never mentioned anyone being “white.” It was completely invented by Heston. I was taken aback as I have never seen a TV station manager ever do something so biased and reckless in all my years in politics.
In my tweets, I was referring to immigration status, not ethnicity or race. But Heston doesn’t seem to know the difference. In his editorial, he never rebuts the law and facts I challenged him on, including a fact check article by the Sacramento Bee that I sent him. The article affirms that California’s sanctuary state law only went into effect in 2018 and did not apply to the tragic death of Officer Singh.
Sorry but @ksbw #JWHeston has revealed himself as a #Trump racist! Has never condemned the mass killings deaths by US citizens against other citizens, nor did he mentioned the guy who killed Davis Police Officer #NatalieCorona! Politicizing the tragedies!!https://t.co/UiCXFieHqA— Luis Alejo (@SupervisorAlejo) January 14, 2019
I did call out Heston for cherry-picking facts and not mentioning the other recent high profile tragic deaths of our fallen officers, such as Davis Police Officer Natalie Corona, and the numerous mass shootings by U.S. citizens. I also urged him to consult legal experts next time.
Throughout my career, I have strongly supported our dedicated police and other public safety officers. I have also denounced those who commit serious crimes and have called for them to be held responsible under both criminal and immigration law. But Heston is again oblivious to these facts.
In my comments, I did state that Heston “revealed himself as a Trump racist” in response to his loaded rhetoric against sanctuary state laws, which is exactly the same as President Trump’s and is similarly misinformed. Heston fails to recognize that California’s sanctuary state law allows cooperation with ICE for a long list of serious crimes. I urged him to read the statute as he also seemed ignorant about the law or didn’t bother to point that out at all.
Last Saturday, I requested equal airtime to provide my rebuttal and to provide the audience the facts about what I did and didn’t say. However, Heston refused. He wrote: “You said what you said; we have said what we said. The audience said what they said. We move on to the next Editorial. Our editorial space is for the weekly opinion we offer; your Twitter and other social media space is your space.” However, KSBW’s audience deserves to get both sides on the air, but Heston seems afraid to let me rebut his false statements.
Lastly, Heston also resorted to his old played-out, political attacks and again called me a “carpet bagger” despite that I’ve lived in Monterey County for over three years, represented this county for six more in the State Assembly and worked here for four years prior to that as a staff attorney for the Monterey County Superior Court. Moreover, my family first came to live in Monterey County as migrant farmworkers starting in the 1950s. Although I love my hometown of Watsonville, Salinas is now my beloved home and I love being an effective champion for my constituents.
When I checked on Heston’s past attack editorials against me, I realized there have been five in less than two years. That’s a record number against any elected official for this station. But again, when Heston cannot argue the substance of law and fact, he instead pounds on the table with political, personal and false attacks. And that’s a shame.
Luis A. Alejo is a Monterey County Supervisor and represents District 1 that includes most of the city limits of Salinas. His opinions are his own and not necessarily those of the Register-Pajaronian.